So I’m not like a fancy olive oil person or anything. I just cook a lot and try to use the good stuff when I can. But there’s this one bottle I bought recently (label says “extra virgin, cold pressed”.. pretty sure it’s legit) and every time I use it on something or just taste it, I get this weird scratchy feeling in the back of my throat. Sometimes it even makes me cough a little.
I thought maybe the oil went bad or something, but the date’s fine and it smells fresh to me?
Is this a thing that happens with certain kinds of olive oil? Or am I just sensitive to something in it?
1 Like
Hey Toby and welcome to the rabbit hole my friend 
That scratchy, peppery thing you’re feeling? Believe it or not, that’s one of the best signs you’ve got your hands on the real deal.
That little cough? That’s oleocanthal talking — a natural phenolic compound found in high-quality extra virgin olive oil. It’s actually been studied for its anti-inflammatory effects (think: the olive oil version of ibuprofen!). Wild, right?
It’s especially strong in fresh oils, often from early harvests where the olives are picked green and punchy. So what you’re tasting isn’t a flaw — it’s the EVOO telling you, “I’m alive!”
A few tips:
- If it smells grassy, fruity, or a little bitter? That’s good.
- If it burns a little but finishes clean? Even better.
- If it just tastes flat or greasy with no kick? That’s when to worry.
You’re not doing anything wrong… you’re actually tuning into a flavor most folks miss.
Try it on something creamy (like mashed potatoes or white beans) and see how that pepper balances everything out. Game changer.
Glad you’re here. Keep tasting, keep asking.
Luca
1 Like
Ahhh got it. Appreciate you breaking it down. I had no clue that little burn could actually be a good sign. Honestly thought maybe the oil was off or too strong for me or something.
It does smell kinda grassy and a bit sharp, so sounds like it checks some of those boxes you mentioned. I’ve mostly just been using it on roasted stuff and bread, but now I’m curious about trying it with something creamy like you said.
Is there a type of oil that’s more mellow but still real EVOO? Just wondering if there’s a middle ground between “flat” and “cough attack”?
Thanks again
1 Like
There’s totally a middle ground! Some high-quality EVOOs are more mellow, round, or buttery, depending on the olive variety and harvest time. Not all of them hit you with the pepper cannon 
If you’re looking for something smoother but still legit, try oils made from Arbequina olives (common in Spain and California)… they tend to be fruitier and gentler on the throat. Also, oils harvested a bit later in the season usually have less bite but still carry great flavor and aroma.
Honestly, it’s kind of like coffee or wine… once you try a few side by side, you start noticing what styles you like best.
You might even enjoy doing a little “taste test” with two or three different bottles, just dipping bread or veggies and seeing what hits you right.
Let me know if you want some suggestions.. always happy to share a few favorites.
Luca